Welcome to Shinnecock Lobster Factory
Welcome to Shinnecock Lobster Factory, where fresh seafood meets culinary passion. Nestled in Southampton, NY, this delightful eatery specializes in lobster-centric dishes crafted with the utmost care. Our story began with a dedication to serving quality lobster rolls, showcasing various tantalizing flavors—from the classic buttery option to the bold Diavolo with roasted tomatoes. Each dish celebrates the sweetness of fresh lobster, lovingly prepared and served in a vibrant, casual setting. With glowing reviews lauding the meaty perfection of our rolls and flavorful lobster salads, every visit promises an unforgettable coastal dining experience. Dive in and savor the best of the sea!
-
42 Montauk Hwy, Southampton, NY 11968 Hotline: (631) 259-3334
Welcome to the Shinnecock Lobster Factory, a seafood gem nestled in the picturesque town of Southampton, NY. Located at 42 Montauk Hwy, this eatery has quickly gained a devoted following for its mouthwatering lobster dishes. With a focus on freshness and creativity, Shinnecock Lobster Factory takes your typical seafood shack experience and elevates it to new heights.
As you approach the restaurant, the scent of buttery lobster fills the air, inviting you to dive into a culinary adventure. The menu boasts an impressive array of lobster rolls, each one crafted with the finest poached lobster, served on a perfectly toasted brioche roll. Highlights include:
- Diavolo Lobster Roll (Guppy) - Fresh poached lobster tossed with roasted tomatoes and spicy peperoncino, priced at $32.24.
- Cajun Lobster Roll (Shark) - For the spice lovers, this features warm sautéed peppers and spicy mayo, available for $36.40.
- Classic Lobster Roll (Shark) - A timeless favorite, lightly tossed with citrus mayo, for $36.40.
- Hamptons Lobster Roll - Generously served with warm butter and chives, a must-try at $36.40.
The restaurant also offers delectable lobster salads and treats like lobster mac and cheese, which have garnered rave reviews from patrons. Take it from customer ‘Urbashi Z.’ who praised the “hefty amount of lobster” and the gooey perfection of the mac and cheese. With options for varying appetites, diners can choose from different sizes: Guppy, Shark, and Whale, which range from 4oz to 8oz, ensuring everyone leaves satisfied.
The atmosphere mirrors the authenticity of a classic seaside shack with a modern twist, making it perfect for families, couples, or solo food enthusiasts. Minimal décor allows the focus to remain on the food, while outdoor seating enhances the dining experience during warmer months. You might even find yourself sharing your love for lobsters with others as you revel in the lively atmosphere.
Feedback from customers like ‘Carolina B.’ and ‘S A.’ highlights how Shinnecock Lobster Factory becomes a must-visit spot, making it a recurring favorite during their trips to the Hamptons. S A. encapsulates the experience well, showcasing that the lobster rolls are “sheer meaty perfection,” a sentiment echoed by many who have tasted their creations.
If your palate craves the ultimate lobster indulgence, don’t overlook Shinnecock Lobster Factory. It’s a culinary journey where every bite tells a story of freshness, quality, and sheer lobster delight. So grab a seat, order at the counter, and prepare your taste buds for a seafood experience that you won’t soon forget!
We came here THREE times while enjoying our stay in the Hamptons! We tried several types: our favorite was the warm one with butter & chives. Our children even enjoyed theirs!
Ok, I tried it at the annual pow wow. Let me tell you, the best lobster roll EVEH!!!! I had the Shinnecock lobster roll with arugula, cherry tomatoes, lemon and olive oil The lobster was shear meaty perfection. Lump chunky lobster tossed with the lemon and oil piled hi on top of a bed of seasoned arugula in a split bun with home made chips. The only fault- it was missing the cherry tomatoes which you definitely needed to balance the acidity of the lemon and arugula. Other than that, I am totally hitting this place up as many times as I can before I go back to the city
Pretty Pretty Good Lobster roll and great fries. It's a drive up shack reminiscent of Maine. They have a dispensary next store so making that your first stop might enhance your dining experience. I'll definitely do it again !!
Absolutely delicious every time. Lots of options for lobster rolls, salads and much more.
Lobster rolls were absolutely delicious (both the hot and cold options!). They give you a hefty amount of lobster which was really nice. We also got the lobster Mac and cheese that was also perfection, so gooey and cheesy! I already want to come back!!
I ordered the largest lobster roll, and it was WAY TOO MUCH FOOD! The lobster roll was great. I believe i got the cajun one, would recommend, wouldnt get again as it had a lot of peppers and onions which I dont like. You self order at the counter and they call your number when the food is ready. It is self-service. There is usually a short line to order. There are seats outside, with parking at the side of the store.
Best lobster rolls in town! Double check their hours before heading over since their posted hours seem to be wrong. On Yelp, it says they close at 8pm, but on their website, it says they close at 7:30pm...we got there at 7:20pm and they were already shut down. So not really sure when they close! We decided to go the next day for lunch! Haha I tried their Diavalo Lobster Roll since I've never seen this option at other lobster roll places. The Diavalo Lobster was fantastic but I didn't like it on the roll. It made the roll very soggy and hard to eat. I kept thinking that the Diavalo Lobster would be fantastic with pasta! Haha Their hot butter Lobster Roll was better. Classic butter goodness. The lobster meat wasn't just claws and knuckles but included actual lobster meat. I really liked that the lobster rolls came in 3 different sizes: Guppy ($31/4oz) Shark ($35/6oz) Whale ($39/8oz) Of course, I wanted bang for the buck and ordered the Whale!...no regrets! :-D We wanted to return to Shinnecock Lobster Factory but ran out of time on our trip. On our next trip, this will be the first place we go! See my photos for their menu. They have lots to offer besides the lobster rolls.